Special Reasons in Perth

Reduced Sentence
Perth Sheriff Court and Justice of the Peace Court

Our client in this case found himself in a bit of a pickle when he was charged with driving without insurance.  Needing to use his partner’s car whilst his was off the road for repairs, and unable to locate his own insurance policy to ascertain whether it conferred a third party extension to do so, he took the sensible step of speaking with his insurer via an online ‘live chat’.  They confirmed that the extension was in place and that he was properly insured to do as he intended.

Unfortunately, this information was wrong and his policy did not permit him to drive another person’s car.

To avoid penalty points being endorsed on his licence, we were instructed to pursue ‘special reasons’.  This is where somebody is guilty of a strict liability offence – in this case, you are either insured to drive or you are not – but the fault for that offence having been committed lies with somebody else.  In the circumstances, it was clear that our client had taken proper steps to ensure he was insured and consequently held a reasonable and honest belief that cover was in place.  The fault lay squarely with the insurance company.    

A proof was assigned with evidence led and at conclusion the Court upheld our special reasons submission, meaning that our client received neither points nor a fine.

Published: 18/02/2020

Need help with a similar case?

Contact Us

See also

Special Reasons Upheld No Points

Our client was stopped by Police on the M8 motorway eastbound following a minor speeding issue. The PNC check confirmed that the vehicle was uninsured. Our client was acquitted of the speeding charge and the court was persuaded to uphold our special reasons argument that it was not appropriate to impose any penalty points in relation to the insurance matter....