A Classic Case of Special Reasons

Kept Licence
Glasgow Sheriff Court and Justice of the Peace Court

This case called in court on 21 August 2019. Normal practice in a special reasons proof is for evidence to be led under oath. It is, however, open for parties to proceed by way of ex parte statements where the Crown and defence agree the evidential basis of the proposed submission. It is thereafter for the court to decide whether that facts as presented and agreed constitute special reasons in terms of the legislation.

The circumstances of the present case were perfectly aligned with a previous legal authority which held that a person is entitled to rely upon an assertion by the owner of a motor vehicle that there is an appropriate policy of insurance in force for that person to drive. Subject, of course, to the proviso that there was no obvious reason to disbelieve that assertion.

The present case involved a fairly routine case where the accused’s parents had assumed responsibility for insuring the vehicle however this arrangement turned out to be ineffective, totally unbeknown to the accused. The court had little difficulty upholding our special reason submission.

Published: 21/08/2019

Need help with a similar case?

Contact Us

See also

Special Reasons Upheld No Points

Our client was stopped by Police on the M8 motorway eastbound following a minor speeding issue. The PNC check confirmed that the vehicle was uninsured. Our client was acquitted of the speeding charge and the court was persuaded to uphold our special reasons argument that it was not appropriate to impose any penalty points in relation to the insurance matter....